You can use your smart phone to browse stories in the comfort of your hand. Simply browse this site on your smart phone.

    Using an RSS Reader you can access most recent stories and other feeds posted on this network.

    SNetwork Recent Stories

BCUC Releases Final Report for Indigenous Utilities Regulation Inquiry

by ahnationtalk on June 3, 202067 Views

May 1, 2020

VANCOUVER – On Thursday, April 30, 2020, the British Columbia Utilities Commission (BCUC) issued its Final Report for the Inquiry into the Regulation of Indigenous Energy Utilities to the Minister responsible for the Hydro and Power Authority Act.

The BCUC’s Inquiry followed an open and transparent engagement process that began in March 2019; it included 11 Community Input Sessions and 8 Draft Report Workshops hosted by the BCUC throughout British Columbia (BC), as well as participation from 21 Registered Interveners, 18 Interested Parties, 12 Letters of Comment, and feedback from representatives of more than 50 different First Nations groups.

The BCUC respects the rights of Indigenous peoples to economic self -determination and self-governance, as laid out in the Articles of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) and sought to reconcile these interests and create mutual benefits for all in its Final Report Recommendations. All of the comments and submissions received during the Inquiry were considered in the BCUC’s development of its Final Report.

Some of the BCUC’s Final Recommendations include:

Regulation of • An Indigenous utility be regulated by a competent arm’s length regulator.
Indigenous Utilities • A First Nation determine the means of regulation of an Indigenous utility
providing services on that First Nation’s reserve land, Westbank Lands or
Sechelt lands provided it demonstrates that it has an arm’s length
complaint and dispute resolution process to protect all ratepayers.
•   Indigenous utilities controlled by the Nisga’a or Tsawwassen First Nation
be exempt from the Utilities Commission Act (UCA).
Definition of an • An Indigenous utility be defined as a public utility for which, as the owner
Indigenous Utility or operator, an Indigenous Nation has control. It is not limited to the types
of services to be provided but includes the provision of public utility
services to persons in its service area.
Ceasing to be an • When a First Nation no longer controls an Indigenous utility, the utility will
Indigenous Utility at that point become a public utility as that term is defined in the UCA and
regulated by the BCUC.

Some of the BCUC’s Final Recommendations include:

Complaints & Appeals •   A panel or body composed of Indigenous people and others with
specialized knowledge, such as First Nations governance, assess a First
Nation’s complaint and dispute resolution process in the context of public
utility regulation as it is practiced in Canada and also within the specific
context of that First Nation, prior to that First Nation’s Indigenous utility
law coming into force.
•   First Nations collectively develop a province-wide appeal body that can be
available to customers of Indigenous utilities who are unable to resolve
their complaints.
•   The BCUC serve as an appeal body until such time as a First Nations
operated body can be established.
Mandatory Reliability •   The BCUC retain jurisdiction with respect to approval, compliance and
Standards (MRS) enforcement of MRS applicable to any entity that may impact the Bulk
Electric System in the province, regardless of who owns or operates the
Safety •   A First Nation determine the means of regulation of safety with respect to
an Indigenous utility.
Retail Access •   The Government of BC review and revise any policies that, in restricting an
Indigenous utility’s access to BC Hydro’s transmission system, may result in
an undue barrier to the First Nation’s pursuit of economic self
Wholesale Energy Sales •   The Government of BC reconsider the Standing Offer Program along with
the cap for that program and any other provision that places undue
economic barriers on potential participants. If the program is restructured
and reintroduced, it should be based on market electricity prices, so that
Indigenous utilities are provided meaningful competitive economic
opportunities while ensuring that all BC Hydro ratepayers are not harmed.
BCUC Regulation •   The BCUC include Indigenous representatives on BCUC panels where
applications of Indigenous utilities are being considered.
•   The BCUC modify its regulatory policies and procedures to better reflect
the objectives of reconciliation in its proceedings.
•   The BCUC ensure that it includes Indigenous people, in both the staff and
Commissioner roles, especially for matters that directly affect First Nations.
Capacity Building •   The BCUC develop, in collaboration with Indigenous representatives, a
strategy to build First Nations’ capacity in Indigenous utility regulation and
a strategy to reduce barriers to the recruitment and placement of
Indigenous people in advisory, staff and Commissioners roles in the BCUC.
•   Where necessary for the implementation of these recommendations, the
Government of BC consider making funding available to First Nations.

For a full and complete list of the BCUC’s Final Recommendations, please refer to its Final Report, or the Final Report Summary available on


On March 11, 2019, the Lieutenant Governor in Council, pursuant to section 5(1) of the UCA, directed the BCUC to provide recommendations to the BC Government regarding the regulation of Indigenous utilities in BC. The terms of the Inquiry are outlined in Order in Council (OIC) No. 108. The BCUC established the Inquiry on March 19, 2019 by Order G-62-19.

The inquiry explored and sought feedback on a number of important questions, including:

What are the characteristics of an “Indigenous Utility” with respect to:

  • The ownership and operation of the utility;
  • What services are provided;
  • Who the services are provided to; and/or,
  • The location or area served by the utility?

Should Indigenous utilities be regulated or not? And if so, how?

  • If they should be regulated, should they be regulated by the UCA or another mechanism?
  • If unregulated, how will the interests of indigenous utility ratepayers be protected?

Currently, under the UCA most utilities with a connection to an Indigenous community are regulated by the BCUC as public utilities. Some utilities have requested exemptions from existing regulatory requirements.

In June, July and September 2019, the BCUC held a series of eleven Community Input Sessions throughout BC to hear comments on the issues raised in the Inquiry. Based on the feedback received during the Inquiry, in November 2019, the Panel released its Draft Report with proposed recommendations regarding the potential regulatory framework for Indigenous-owned and operated energy utilities in BC. In late 2019 and early 2020, the BCUC hosted eight Draft Report Workshops to gather feedback on its proposed recommendations. All of the comments and submissions received during the Inquiry, were considered in the BCUC’s development of its Final Report.

For more information about the Inquiry, please see the proceeding page on the BCUC website here.

About the BCUC

The BCUC is a regulatory agency responsible for the oversight of energy utilities and compulsory auto insurance in British Columbia. It is the BCUC’s role to balance the interests of customers with the interests of the businesses it regulates. The BCUC carries out fair and transparent reviews of matters within its jurisdiction and considers public input where public interest is impacted.


Krissy Van Loon

Manager, Communications

Phone: 604.660.4727



Send To Friend Email Print Story

Comments are closed.

NationTalk Partners & Sponsors Learn More